Guestbook Page Five
Added: 3/30/2005
Submitted by
Name: mark mior
Comments:
"recently i read "under the red sea sun" and "on the bottom".i am truly impressed with the man and his writing.at this time i read only non fiction and personal experience is my favorite.i found ellsberg by accident at a used book sale.i am hooked, i can`t what to read no banners and the far shore .when i find them ."
Added: 3/21/2005
Submitted by
Name: Robert Clifford
Comments:
"I am in shock! I couldn't believe my eyes when, looking for books by one of my all time heroes, I found a website dedicated to him. My father was a WWII veteran of the CBI theater who was a great reader of adventure stories. My two brothers and I grew up in the 60's and 70's reading many of these books. Of all the books I have read in my life, never have I experienced an author who can captivate me to the extent that at 47 years of age, after a fairly adventurous life myself, I can settle down with "Under the Red Sea Sun" or "No Banners, No Bugles", both of which I have read cover to cover several times, and keep reading until I can't keep my eyes open any longer. For my late father, my two brothers, and I, an airman, soldier, and sailor, respectively, our eternal gratitude to the type of man of both action and thought who can write such compelling and inspirational works. I look forward now to exploring your website. Robert Clifford"
Added: 3/18/2005
Submitted by
Name: Glenn Lycan
Comments:
"While watching the TV program "Deep Sea Detectives", my wife asked where I became interested in diving. I said "That's easy to answer. While in high school in 1948 I found a book "On The Bottom" which started me in reading everything by Comander Ellsberg that I could find." His name has over the years has been the first search whenever I enter a library or bookstore.
Last evening when I found your website I could not go to bed until I finished reading the diary of the cruise on the Fairfax.
Thank You for keeping tour Grandfathers writings alive!"
Added: 2/26/2005
Submitted by
Name: Doyle Hodges
Comments:
"I am a Naval officer, on my way to command a salvage ship in the Pacific. I ran across a copy of On the Bottom in a used bookstore, and stumbled into this site by accident. Thanks for maintaining such a wonderful resource on a legend in Navy salvage."
Added: 2/26/2005
Submitted by
Name: Avi-Brillant
Comments:
"Under the Red-Sea Sun
By : Commander Edward Ellsberg
Very interesting book on WW2 salvage in the Red Sea.
I heard the name of Admiral Ellsberg from my late father. It was during an interview he gave to the Israeli Navy Veterans history branch from the Clandestine and Immigration Navy Museum in Haifa.There he told the story about his service in Massawa Eritrea and showed us many photos and Letters. Then I found in his Naval Technical Library he had several books of that time Commander Ellsber. One of them told his story. My father New CDR Ellsberg personally. This book describes the salvage work in the Massaawa harbor in Eritrea. This is a professional description of determined people in a hard climate area, that their goal was to bring back the Massaawa harbor into full operation for the allies. This is not a heroic war description with high strategy. This is the story of people. As a son of a Jewish Royal-Navy Officer volunteer from Palestine during the British mandate in Israel, I am familiar with this story. My father served there during 1942-1943. All the knowledge from his service was used by him to build the Young Israeli Navy in 1948. His experience from the service in the Royal Navy was used by him to define the Israeli Navy Salvage unit YALTAM and establishing all damage control branch as a professional unit. The Palestinians Jewish Volunteers in Massawa were very appreciated by the British and the Americans for their contribution in the war efforts against the evil Nazi regime. Admiral Ellsberg never hidden his origin and was a proud Jew. At the early strides he gave aid and guidance to the young Israeli Navy. But he was not the only one. For instance the Israeli Admiral of the Navy at its early days was USN Commander Paul-Schulman. My late father rank in the Israeli Navy was Lieutenant Commander. retired in 1962. His profession was Naval Architect. In 1969 he designed the fueling ship M.V Lea at the Gibraltar and the backup ship M.V Nethanyah at the Biscay bay for the Missile Boats. These boats were taken from the French by force by means of deception. This operation was during the French embargo led by the French presidents Charles De-Gulla and George Pompidou and is known as the Cherbourg Operation Noa. Those boats made the first sea to sea missile warfare in Naval History at 73. This is the first time ECM (electronic counter measures) and EW (electronic warfare) were used. It was a great victory without any single casualty to the Israeli Navy. This strategy was adopted by the USN. If any one is doing an history research on the Massawa Volunteers to the Royal-Navy from Israel (RNVR), or the Israeli Navy at the beginning send me an Email to Avi-Brillant Email address: avibrillant@hotmail.com To all interest on Navy I can recommend to read all the books of Admiral Ellsberg as well as to look for the book ?The Boats of Cherbourg? by Abraham Rabinovich.
All the best
Kol Toov
Shalom
Avi-Brillant"
Added: 2/24/2005
Submitted by
Name: David Farragut Rohde
Comments:
"Dear Ted
I am a Navy Junior (my Dad is a Retired Naval Officer) and I am a Marine. My professional library has many of your grandfather's books, and I have always enjoyed reading and re-reading them.
thanks very much for the nice website.
Semper Fi
David"
Added: 2/22/2005
Submitted by
Name: Richard De Luca
Comments:
"Commander Ellsberg was my first literary hero. I discovered him when I was in the ninth grade, and I enthusiastically read several of his books.
I recently acquired his "Under the Red Sea" and just finished reading it this morning. Wow!! What a man!!
I honor his memory.
Sincerely,
Dick De Luca"
Added: 2/22/2005
Submitted by
Name: MR.MUGU
Comments:
"Very good site, Divers are advised to check here.Good luck"
Added: 2/21/2005
Submitted by
Name: Steve Taylor
Comments:
"Mr. Pollard,I had no idea that there was a web site dedicated to Edward Ellsberg.Just out of curiousity I put his name in the browser and this site popped up. I have collected his books for years, my favorites have been Under the Red Sea Sun and No Banners No Bugles. I have read so much about him, I wished I could have met him personaly he was a true American Hero.Thanks for a web site honoring your Grandfather. Sincerely Steven J.Taylor"
Added: 2/13/2005
Submitted by
Name: Greg MacGarva
Comments:
"Dear Mr Pollard,
I have been a great fan of Admiral Ellsberg since the 3rd grade when I started reading On the Bottom and the rest of the books in that series. When I was in 4th grade I wrote a letter to him and much to my delight I received a very nice one in return which became a keepsake. I continued to read of his exploits in his non-fiction books as I got older. I am from a military family, my father having served in the Navy, Merchant Marine, and Coast Guard for a total of 30 years' service. I graduated from the Coast Guard Academy in 1976 and 1980 saw me as Assistant engineer on board a Polar Icebreaker. We spent many months in the ice, both north and south and during a north trip I read Hell on Ice, and I wrote him again and sent some photos of my ship. He again very kindly wrote me back - the handwriting reflecting a 14 year timespan since his previous letter, but what a wonderful letter and, like the other, it too remains a treasured keepsake.
Now my son will be carrying our military tradition forward another generation as he just received an appointment to Annapolis, Class of 2009. He too read many of Admiral Ellsberg's books growing up - when he was quite small and we were living in DC I took him to see the Naval Academy, and we viewed the limestone monument dedicated to the crew of the Jeannette.
Very sincerly,
Greg MacGarva
CDR, USCG (ret)
USCGA Class of 1976
P.S. The other day I wrote to the History Channel asking them why on earth they hadn't featured Admiral Ellsberg on a segment of "Biography"."
Added: 2/11/2005
Submitted by
Name: Emily Popovich
Comments:
Just finished Under The Red Sea Sun. What an amazing guy! Of course everyone around him would be inspired to work as hard as they could. So glad he was on our side!
Added: 2/3/2005
Submitted by
Name: JOHN EDWARDS
Comments:
"I have collected all of the Ellsberg books and have been a fan for many years, as a fellow diver and engineer I have nothing but admiration for his exploits."
Added: 1/29/2005
Submitted by
Name: Richard M. Huckeby
Comments:
"My 4th grade teacher, Mrs Whitlock, got me reading Ellsberg's novels in 1940. I devoured them and can even now quote from some of them.
I tried to introduce my own five children to these books in the 1960s but alas! could not find any of them.
Ellsberg made me want to be a naval officer (I lived in Denver--hardly a naval environment) but after I was unable to pass the eye exam for Naval ROTC at Colo Univ, I ended up going to law school.
I now live in Virgina, forty miles west of Norfolk, and can go look at boats and ships all I want.
But my fascination these days is with RC steamboats, typically 36" long, powered with live steam.
I used to know a lot about the Ellsberg underwater torch, but note it is not mentioned anywhere on your website"
Added: 1/20/2005
Submitted by
Name: Parker C. Wiseman
Comments:
"Dear Mr. Pollard,
Both I and my grand-father met RADM Ellsberg although at widely different times. I have written you a letter about our connections to your grandfather. Could you send me an e-mail message telling me where to send it? Here? Or elsewhere?
Thank you,
Parker C. Wiseman, Chatham, MA
Parker C. Wiseman, Chatham, MA"
Added: 1/18/2005
Submitted by
Name: william f. pack
Comments:
"interested in all navel salvage and navel ships,also wooden sailing ships.ALL FICTION"
Added: 12/31/2004
Submitted by
Name: Roy Rosenblum
Comments:
Thank you so much for a great website and tribute to one of my favorite authors. I read On the Bottom back in the late fourties and I was hooked. I read several more of his books and enjoyed everyone. At age 73 I still think back to CMDR Ellsberg and his formidable exploits. I now want to introduce him to my Grandson. Thanks again for the work you are doing in keeping your your grandfathers exploits alive..
Added: 12/25/2004
Submitted by
Name: David B Dawes
Comments:
"I live in Muskegon, Mi where we have four historic ships. No less than:USS 236, The 'Silversides' LST '393', USS 'MacLain', a 1927 Coast Guard Cutter and the USS 'Milwaukee Clipper', a ship tha tis oldert han the 'Titanic'. Your grandfather would just love these ships. John Niedermeir's son has actually been a guest speaker here and so has Edward Beach, Jr. Maybe you could come to visit sometime. I could personally give you a tour of each of these ships as I've done projects on all four of them. Let me know..."
Added: 12/12/2004
Submitted by
Name: Gary Wild
Comments:
"First read Under The Red Sea Sun in the mid '50's when in hi school, recently acquired my onw copy and appreciate the skill, work and all that was done for this country. We need more Edward Ellsberg's"
Added: 11/23/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Alan S. Pollack, Esq."
Comments:
"Hi Ted - We just met, I'm the videographer at Westfield Community Television. I just ordered a few books and will return to your great website to read more ! Thanks."
Added: 11/20/2004
Submitted by
Name: Jim Moody
Comments:
"I just finished reading On The Bottom for at least the fourth time. I first read it in high school around 1959. I was always intrigued by diving and even did some minor diving myself later. Then found it in the UWF library and read it again about 1990. About 2000 I copied it from online and read it again. I just recently dug the pages out of a manila folder, put them in a notebook binder and read it a fourth time. I'm hoping that it will not be the last time."
Added: 11/19/2004
Submitted by
Name: Ed Biggs
Comments:
Under the Red Sea Sun and No Banners No Bugles were both read in High School. They way they were written left a lasting memory. I have acquired Under the Red Sea Sun and have enjoyed it once again. My sons will get it to read as well. I much admire the American Hero Edward Ellsberg. EDB
Added: 11/18/2004
Submitted by
Name: Don Knott
Comments:
Thank you for making this available. Is it possible to purchase prints of photographs of his work. Such as the HMS Dido in dry dock at Massawa. Thank you.
Added: 11/7/2004
Submitted by
Name: "David T. Holland, CWO, U.S.C.G."
Comments:
I just completed reading "ON THE BOTTOM" in two days. What an inspirational read! It would have been an honor to work along side any of those men!
Added: 10/24/2004
Submitted by
Name: Charles Bauer
Comments:
I admired Adm. Ellsberg very much. He is one of my heroes!
Added: 9/30/2004
Submitted by
Name: Lawrence Jacobi
Comments:
I read on the bottom while in high school over 50 years ago. I was thrilled Flat Hammock Press released the book again.
Added: 8/26/2004
Submitted by
Name: Gregory Lee
Comments:
"I'm a Naval Architect. I Recently found & read Ellsberg Books, including Under the Red Sea Sun & Hell On Ice. Really first rate. I'm going to try to get copies of most of the other books by Ellsberg. Any sources you could identify would be helpful. I have the re-print of On the Bottom on order."
Added: 8/20/2004
Submitted by
Name: Edward Lukacs
Comments:
"If, in my lifetime, there was one naval officer who I'd have liked to meet, he was Edward Ellsberg. Discovering "Under the Red Sea Sun" in my elementary school's library, I eventually read every book that he wrolte, and own hardbound copies of all but one today. In an age that values ethics along with yesterday's unrefrigerated fish, I hope and pray that our country can again produce people of his calibre and with his drive, energy, and unwavering ethics."
Added: 8/19/2004
Submitted by
Name: Garry Greenstein
Comments:
"I started reading the Commander's books in Junior High School, and continued as an adult. I am a great admirer of his. GGG"
Added: 8/8/2004
Submitted by
Name: William Sumner
Comments:
"More than 40 years ago I first read Men Under The Sea. Recently, I found the book in storage-read it again. Where can I find other Ellsberg stories to read on the internet?"
Added: 8/7/2004
Submitted by
Name: John P. Kelley
Comments:
"As a boy I read every Ellsberg book I could find. When I took Diving Training with Class 13 EOD (1953) in Indian Head I knew where everything was and how it worked. All from reading LCDR Edward Ellsberg's books. I went into Nuclear and never dove again. Now in retirement I'm going to read the booka over again. I'm glad you took the trouble to put all this together. Thanks, Jack Kelley"
Added: 8/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: Henry Bick
Comments:
a most remarkable man.His work should never be forgotten.in my eyes a great hero.......
Added: 7/15/2004
Submitted by
Name: Mike Brush
Comments:
I found a copy of the new edition of On The Bottom at the book store recently and have been absolutley fascinated by what I have been reading. It's a great story. I wish I had learned about this a long time ago.
Added: 7/5/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Chip McCord, CAPT, USN (Ret)"
Comments:
RADM Ellsberg was an inspiration to generations of Divers and Salvors. He was the first (and still the best) in detailing the dangers and challenges while working on and under the ocean's surface (esp. in remote ares like Eritrea). Thanks for the website and keeping the memory of a true Navy Salvor alive.
Added: 7/2/2004
Submitted by
Name: Spencer Boyce
Comments:
I read your grandfather's books as a boy. No doubt that his writings contributed to my love of the sea and all things related to maritime salvage. Thanks for putting the website up.
Added: 6/28/2004
Submitted by
Name: Sue
Comments:
"Greetings. Your web site is very well done. Thank you for sharing your information. My great-uncle, Austin St. "Clair" Byrne worked on the salvage operations with Cmdr. Ellsberg. I have some info posted on my Byrne web site (link at left). Thanks again! Sue"
Added: 6/27/2004
Submitted by
Name: Terry A. Gardner
Comments:
"I first read Ellsbergs works, starting with Under the Red Sea Sun in high school. I now own my own copies of some of his works as well. Having spent 26 years in the US Navy and Reserve, I have found Ellsberg's books something of an inspiration to my own career in naval engineering.
Terry A. Gardner, EMC(SW) USNR"
Added: 6/21/2004
Submitted by
Name: Gary Kingzett
Comments:
"Thank you for helping us remember this great American. And now, since you and he have rekindled my memories, I will have to search for the rest of his books. Gary"
Added: 6/20/2004
Submitted by
Name: JERRY HODGE
Comments:
"Hi there i have read most of your grandfathers books. many years ago i just became aware though this website of the books i missed, I will be looking forward tom reading those as soon as possible, i wish i could have dived with commander Ellsberg in those days."
Added: 5/22/2004
Submitted by
Name: Alex Mello
Comments:
"Dear Sir,
Recently I became the temporary owner of a magnificent book entitled "Under The Red Sea Sun" written by your Grandfather. The book I have was published by Dodd, Mead & Company in 1946 and is in excellent condition. I can't remember the last time I read such an account of history with such desire and velocity. Your Grandfather may have passed away, but his inspiration as a man, a leader, and innovator will for always claim a piece of my memory.
Sincerely,
Alex Mello"
Added: 5/21/2004
Submitted by
Name: Steve Mellor
Comments:
Great work Ted. Ready to research other families?
Added: 4/26/2004
Submitted by
Name: Lew Nuckols
Comments:
"Ted, Great website!"
Added: 4/22/2004
Submitted by
Name: Doug Hender
Comments:
I have been a great fan of Edward Ellsberg since the late 1940's. Over the years I have read most of his books.
Added: 4/12/2004
Submitted by
Name: Chuck Milne
Comments:
"I borrowed "No Banners, No Bugles" from my uncle. Wonderful book! Amazing what he did with what he had."
Added: 4/11/2004
Submitted by
Name: Robert L Patch
Comments:
"My dad had several of his books and I read them as a preteen. Wanted to go into salvage but as bad eyesight would of limited me to internal ship work became an Engineer instead (Chemical, BS)."03/29/2004-15:20"
Added: 3/29/2004
Submitted by
Name: RAY SCHAEFER
Comments:
"GREAT SALVAGE ENGINEER, JUST WISH I COULD HAVE HAD A CHANCE TO WORK WITH HIM."
Added: 3/16/2004
Submitted by
Name: LAURENCE BAKER
Comments:
"Have read all of CMDR Ellsberg's books thru the years. Glad I found this Site for it has much information not otherwise available. My Heartfelt Thanks. LAURENCE BAKER, MSGT/USAF/RET"
Added: 3/2/2004
Submitted by
Name: Robert Ballou
Comments:
"Thank you for posting this web site and doing so much to honor your grandfather. I grew up reading his books after my older brother had finished reading them! His writing was so graphic that you could "see" everything in your minds eye. I'm now 64 and was unaware of the last book - The Far Shore - but now that I am, I will find a copy and read it for sure. Thanks again for all your efforts."
Added: 2/19/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Charles W. Roop, LCDR, USN (ret)"
Comments:
A great man and an inspiration to any of us who ever worked in ship salvage.
Added: 2/14/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Ralph Duncan, Lcdr, USN (Ret)"
Comments:
"I look forward to reading the biography. As a retired USN salvage officer, I too have admired the deeds of Edward Ellsberg. Under the Red Sea Sun, my favorite."
Added: 2/5/2004
Submitted by
Name: Sarah Hawke
Comments:
"I'm sorry, I couldn't get my web software to work correctly, and I didn't understand why those *'s kept showing up - I did not mean to flood this guestbook. Sorry :("
Added: 2/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: John
Comments:
"hi there, i really enjoyed your website."
Added: 2/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: D.G. Fitton
Comments:
"A terrific man, and fantastic author. My favorite. I have many copies of his books, having been collecting them for some time. I am interested in selling some of them, email me with your interest."
Added: 2/2/2004
Submitted by
Name: Michael R. Haeser
Comments:
In rememberance of Admiral Ellsberg who was a power of example to me since I read his first book "On The Bottom "when I was 11 years old and for my son who is about to be promoted to Chief Engineer in the United States Merchant Marine.
Added: 1/27/2004
Submitted by
Name: Paul Marak
Comments:
This is great ! I have read all of your father's books except Salvage man. I can only find it for $150. a little out of my price range.
Thank you Paul Marak
S/V Ryokosha in Mexico
Added: 1/21/2004
Submitted by
Name: John Hyatt
Comments:
Nice to have a new batch of letters (Normandy # 64-95) up since I last visited the site. Thanks! Are there more to come?
Added: 1/13/2004
Submitted by
Name: george hill
Comments:
"Thank you very much for the website. I also started reading in JrHS abt 1949 and he was my favorite author then and I still love and collect his books. I don't yet understand why people can be so brave. My first reaction to "Hell On Ice" was that it was just too morbid, but eventually I had to read it, and then was inspired by the terrific reserves of strength they called up, which we are normally very unaware. A friend collected EE's books at my request and so I have duplicates of Hell On Ice and Captain Paul if some one wants them. I would like to visit your library.
Thanks again."
Added: 1/6/2004
Submitted by
Name: John Bayer
Comments:
Glad to help anyone find any Ellsberg title used.
Added: 1/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: Edward Niedermair
Comments:
"A great web site for a great man! My dad, John C. Niedermair, was involved with the S-51 salvage and the book "On The Bottom" is very dear to me. I wanted to purchase the new edition and could not come up with it on Amazon. It would be nice if this site had a link to the purchase of all of Admiral Ellsbergs wonderful books. "
Added: 12/17/2003
Submitted by
Name: Janet Young
Comments:
I read Passport for Jennifer about 10 years ago. There was a copy in the library. I often think about it and appreciate all what these folks went through.
Added: 12/5/2003
Submitted by
Name: john f shima
Comments:
"I have been a fan of Cmdr Elsberg since the age of 9, having read all his books. Served in the USN as QM on PCS in Key West. He was the first author I ever followed."
Added: 12/3/2003
Submitted by
Name: Paul L. Kidd
Comments:
"On a recent pilgrimage to Portsmouth, NH, I found an excellent old copy of "On The Bottom," which I am now enjoying immensely. As an old Smoke Boat sailor (Ret.) I consider myself something of an amature historian on submarine disasters. You can appreciate how glad I was to find this excellent website!"
Added: 11/11/2003
Submitted by
Name: Andrew Melomet
Comments:
Picked up a copy of Pigboats from Abebooks.com. and am preparing a 2004 presentation of Hell Below for the Bay Area chapters of The Great War Society. Bought the 2 books available from Flat Hammock Press. Any possibility of future reprints such as the WWII trilogy? This is a superb website and I'm glad I found it.
Added: 11/7/2003
Submitted by
Name: Anne Trembley
Comments:
I only wish they would print a new enlarged edition of the biography so I could read it. But I understand the Navy does not like attention drawn to men who succeed against impossible odds.
Added: 10/30/2003
Submitted by
Name: George Herold
Comments:
"I was on the S-27 1941/1942 until it was lost 19 June "42. I confess not having read much of his stuff, but will visit library for sure now."
Added: 10/4/2003
Submitted by
Name: Andy Werback
Comments:
"His books are just incredible. Under the Red Sea Sun is an amazing story of what it took to get the job done. I've managed to check a few of the events he describes, such as a Liberty ship blowing up off North Africa, fully documented elsewhere."
Added: 9/19/2003
Submitted by
Name: Tom Ellsberg
Comments:
I was supprised to see so many people still interested in my Uncle.
Added: 9/9/2003
Submitted by
Name: Jerry Guenther
Comments:
I have collected and read all of Edwards books and have read some of them two and three times. Can you help me locate a copy of Aldens book Ellsberg and the U.S. navy. Thanks very much. Jerry guenther
Added: 8/25/2003
Submitted by
Name: Joseph J. Gannon
Comments:
As a young boy (now 58) I thrilled to the tales in Commander Ellsberg's books. I brought him up at dinner to someone who was applauding the new book on the Squalus rescue. JJG
Added: 8/20/2003
Submitted by
Name: dennis f morse
Comments:
nice site. i am a retired usn master diver. also i was one of four divers who salvaged the andrea doria statue from the ship of the same name.
Added: 8/11/2003
Submitted by
Name: Sandra Straub
Comments:
"I was wondering if there is any way I can get a copy of the book "Blow All Ballast"? My father was on the ship that rescued them (Falcon, I think) and his name in mentioned in the book - John Burton Smith. Thank you for your help."
Added: 8/8/2003
Submitted by
Name: Craig Rothhammer
Comments:
"Thank you for dedicating this excellent website to your Grandfathers Naval career. He is a beacon for all Naval Salvors, and our respect and admiration for him is fathomless.
Anchor's Aweigh
Craig Rothhammer
Board Member
National Association of Fleet Tug Sailors - the Salvage Navy.
"The Difficult We Do Today, The Impossible May Take Until Tomorrow"
Added: 7/10/2003
Submitted by
Name: Steve Masticola
Comments:
"Just finished No Banners, No Bugles last night. Was wondering why, when he was trying to raise the Grand Dock, he didn't think of substituting easy-to-make mercury or water manometers for the low-preessure gauges that he couldn't get. That's the one place I caught him not taking advantage of every possible opportunity, but I guess he had an excuse that he was about to collapse from nervous exhaustion. Excellent book."
Added: 7/9/2003
ubmitted by
Name: Montgomery Sabin
Comments:
"I read most of Edward Ellsberg's books when I was a youngster. In fact, I used to hide one his books inside my regular class room text book and read it during class instead of the what I was supposed to be reading. Loved each and every word in every book and wish that he could have written more and more."
Added: 7/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: Thomas Tully
Comments:
Correction to last message. After"Under The Red Sea Sun"1946 should read "no Banners No Bugles"(1949).Then The Far Shore"(1959). Tom Tully
Added: 6/28/2003
Submitted by
Name: Thomas Tully
Comments:
"First read "On The Bottom" as a H.S. english Assignment in 1948 and have been interested.in him ever since. I have read almost all of his books and have "On The Bottom" (1955)," Under The Red Sea Sun(1946),"Under The Red Sea Sun"(1949)and "No Banners,No Bugles"(pocket book(1959).A friend found this site for me trying to find "salvage Man" after I saw a review in "Sea Classics" magazine.Please let me know when and if you con get it published again.
Thomas Tully"
Added: 6/28/2003
Submitted by
Name: James Myers
Comments:
"I was a big fan of Adm. Ellsburg, my first book was "On the Bottom". That was in the 1970's, my one real regret was not tracking him down and getting him to sign my copy."
Added: 6/21/2003
Submitted by
Name: Mark Mooney
Comments:
"Finally got to start 'Captain Paul' which I rediscovered recently in my library, having claimed it from my Grandparents estate a few years ago. I'm an amateur Naval History buff and am totally enthralled with this JPJ Novel which launched a web search to discover more on author and book. Do you have any idea how much of this 'Novel' is based on factual events? It wonderful to discover an alumni with such literary skill(amongst many other talents, I see in viewing the website). USNA 1978."
Added: 6/20/2003
Submitted by
Name: Jean York
Comments:
"My father is a big fan of Edward Ellsberg. Any advice on where/how to find copies of his books? He already has Captain Paul, Hell on Ice, Thirty Fathoms Deep, and On the Bottom. The others are pretty tough to locate. And thanks for a great web-site!"
Added: 6/16/2003
Submitted by
Name: John Bayer
Comments:
"Hello Ted: Great site on your Grandfather! I am a Naval Reserve officer on recall to active duty. Having had 4 different ratings as an enlisted man during 24 years enlisted service, I was fortunate to have attended 2nd Class DV school in San Diego in 1984. I didn't finish after deciding to leave active duty at the time. Your Grandfather's writings were what inspired me to go there in the first place, however, and to one day pursue underwater archaeology. Our class had our familiarization dives in the few remaining Mark V suits, as the transition to the Mk 12 was happening... hope you have fun with your dive with Dave!
Any word on the reprint of the Alden book?
Sincerely,
John Bayer
ENS, USNR (ex-IS1, QM1, AW1)"
Added: 6/7/2003
Submitted by
Name: Jim Allen
Comments:
"Ted,
Great website. I especially enjoyed the WWII letters. By a sheer and magnificent coincidence, I stumbled upon this website while rereading my old copy of "On the Bottom." I think I'll start on "Under the Red Sea Sun" next. Ted, we haven't spoken for some time, but I'm glad the iography on your grandfather got done... even if it wasn't by me! Best Wishes. Jim Allen"
Added: 6/3/2003
Submitted by
Name: Eric Anderson
Comments:
"I found the books "Under the Red Sea Sun" and "No Bugles, No Banners" in my high school library, and was hooked - more that 20 years ago! As a working engineer, I would like to read more of his technical papers, as well as re-reading his books. I was shocked to find out that he was not listed at the Navy Memorial Museum when I visited in 2000 - and I firmly believe that the Navy is overdue in naming a ship for him - And the Salvage School!!! I had thought that the neglect was due to RADM Ellsberg being Jewish, but I see that it was also due to his being a Naval Constructor, rather than a Line Officer... The Senators from Colorado and New York should get signed up for this!"
Added: 5/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: David H. Grover
Comments:
"As a long-time Ellsworth reader and fan, I'm delighted that he is being re-discovered as one of the real heroes of World War II. As a long-ago graduate of the Navy Salvage School I can attest to the fact that the salvage establishment did not assist in publicizing his accomplishments. As a writer these days, I'll try to do what I can to apread the word about his role in salvage work. Dave Grover"
Added: 4/21/2003
Submitted by
Name: Laurel Jacobs
Comments:
I am interested in Edward Ellsberg because I am trying to find a book that my Uncle needs to complete his collection. It is Passport For Jennifer. If anyone knows where I can get a copy - Please email me.
Added: 3/29/2003
Submitted by
Name: Leonard Schechtman
Comments:
I am a big fan.
Added: 3/29/2003
Submitted by
Name: Bob Cloutman
Comments:
Great site Ted. I think you know what a fan I am of your grandfather. I couldn't be happier that someone is preserving his legacy.
Added: 1/31/2003
Submitted by
Name: Joel M. Kauffman
Comments:
Enjoyed the fiction as a teenager. Realized what an honest hero Ellsberg was by reading the non-fiction. Wow!
Added: 1/28/2003
Submitted by
Name: Steve Masticola
Comments:
"I ran into Under the Red Sea Sun quite by accident. Although I'd read at least one other excellent book about salvage (Gray Seas Under by Mowat), I'd never known that the business could be so fascinating. Comander Ellsberg was an excellent writer and a real hero. I hope we're still making men like him."
Added: 1/15/2003
Submitted by
Name: Charles Hall
Comments:
Nice looking website! Now if you can get his other books back in print!
Added: 1/14/2003
Submitted by
Name: Frank T. Chapman
Comments:
I have an original copy of "On The Bottom" since sometime in the 1940s. I have read it several times and it is always exciting. I'm happy to see it reprinted.
Added: 1/9/2003
Submitted by
Name: David J Young
Comments:
I was stationed in Ethiopia in the mid '60's and it was a nice day when I discovered "Under the Red Sea Sun" in a flea market. Edward Ellsberg was a fascinating man and have enjoyed two other books he's written.Great countries are made by great men.
Added: 1/3/2003
Submitted by
Name: Bill Barnum
Comments:
Boy could he write.If you read them all I agree the Navy should name a ship in his name.
Added: 1/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: REFIK ABBAS
Comments:
"Hello,
I became a diver because I was directed by two men : J.Y. Cousteau and the author of no banners, no bugles, the admiral E. Elsberg. Really thanks for your site .
R.ABBAS from Algeria"
Added: 1/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: Robert H. Arbuckle Jr.
Comments:
Ellsberg was a true hero.
Added: 1/1/2003
Submitted by
Name: Lee Parsons
Comments:
"I am a fan of all of Edward's Ellsbergs books. I have been unable to find a copy of 'S-54', any suggestions?"
Added: 12/28/2002
Submitted by
Name: John T. Thurmond
Comments:
"Glad to see that the author of two of my favored books back in high school -- maybe before, has some well deserved attention. The two were, of course "Red Sea Sun" and "No Banners." Trying to be a novelist in my retirement (a fossil expert trying to evade becoming one myself) and used an incident -- the raising of "Spahi" at Oran -- as the basis for something just written. "
Added: 12/22/2002
Submitted by
Name: Mark Stoffan
Comments:
"I grew up reading Edward Ellsberg's books in junior high and high school, and own copies of some of them. I didn't know at the time that he was still alive and living quite close to me in Maine. I've since regretted that I never had the chance to meet him. He was a brilliant man, a credit to the Navy and his country, and he should be better remembered than he is. Perhaps we should petition the Navy to name a ship in Ellsberg's memory. I hope you are successful in getting Alden's bio republished. We have one of the 1500 original copies in our library. "
Added: 12/20/2002
Submitted by
Name: Jeffrey M. Lane
Comments:
"Great site, I am a former Army Diver and am interested in all stories and accounts about military diving I can find. Looking forward to going down the list of publications!!"
Added: 12/19/2002
Submitted by
Name: Norm Mitchell
Comments:
Like so many I read Comm. E.E. books in Jr. High in the 1950s. About 10 yrs. ago went looking for copies of his books. Have reread and have copies of most of them. What examples of outstanding human character traits. Wish these books could be introducted to our Jr. Highers today. Thanks very much for this web site. Question what ever happend to the bell S-51 that EE gave to Francis Smith? what ever happen to F.Smith?
Added: 12/17/2002
Submitted by
Name: Ralph K. Pedersen
Comments:
"I came across "Under the Red Sea Sun" quite by accident. I find it thoroughly engrossing particulary as I myself have spent time in Massawa and Eritrea (as an underwater archaeologist)dealing with the intractable. Great book, and I look forward to reading more!"
Added: 12/17/2002
Submitted by
Name: Zalman Lachman
Comments:
"I picked up "On The Bottom" at a used bookstore several years ago, and enjoyed it especially for the way the average reader is introduced to the arcane world of underwater salvage and hard-helmet diving. I have always wanted to know more about your grandfather's life, and Alden's book is very difficult to find. Thank you for sharing the details here, Ted. This is a wonderful site. In my opinion, though it is not autobiographical, "Hell On Ice," is the best written and most gripping of the Ellsberg titles."
Added: 12/12/2002
Submitted by
Name: Jay Clarke
Comments:
I remember reading "Under the Red Sea Sun" and "On the Bottom" in High School in the late 50's. Great Story. I thought of it today and ran a search and found this wedsite. Glad to honor this wonderful author and adventurer.
Added: 12/11/2002
Submitted by
Name: Mike Van Hove
Comments:
"As a boy in Jr Hi, I read a series of books about subs and salvaging subs. They were written (I tought) by a Commander Edward Ellsberg. Seems like the stories had a common crew woven into the various books. I looked at the list of books on your website, but nothing sounds familiar. Is there another author by the name of Edward Ellberg? They were great stories and I'd like to get them for my Grandsons to read, but havn't had any luck at the library. Am I just not remembering correctly, or is it the trilogy that I read, years ago. Seems like there were far more that just 3 books in the series. If you have the time, I'd love to hear from you. I just came across your Grandfathers name in Vol III of Samuel Elliot Morisons "History of Naval Operations in World War II", where he is mentioned for his salvage work in North Africa. That name jumped off the page at me, and here I am. Thank you for maintaining this site!!
Mike Van Hove
mvanhove@earthlink.net"
Added: 12/10/2002
Submitted by
Name: Michael B. Achorn
Comments:
"I first read "Under the Red Sea Sun", some 45 years ago. Thanks to EBay I have my own copy of this wondrful book. Nice to see RADM Ellsberg is remembered."
Added: 11/30/2002
Submitted by
Name: Dave Sutton
Comments:
"Kudus to Ted for keeping the flame of his Grandfathers work alive. Ted: We'll get you diving in that Mark-V helmet this spring, I promise!
Respectfully,
Dave Sutton"
Added: 11/29/2002
Submitted by
Name: John A. Hyatt
Comments:
"What a delight to discover the Ellsberg website! Finding the WWII letters was a particular treat - I've printed them all out and will read through them some wintry evening soon.
I read "On The Bottom" and several of the novels while in high school in the '60's, and since then I have re-read "On The Bottom" and "Under the Red Sea Sun" every 5 years or so. My interest in marine salvage and diving is only of the armchair variety, but Ellsberg has remained to this day a hero and role model to me: A man who knew how to get things done, and who cared more about the accomplishment of useful tasks than the mere appearance and trappings of success. "
Added: 11/15/2002
Submitted by
Name: "Col. Lee Butler, US Army, Ret."
Comments:
Admiral Ellsberg was on of my favorite authors when I was growing up. He introduced me to th adventures of ocean salvage. Commander Ellsberg (as he was called when he wrote some of the books I read) was one of the many authors who affected my life in varying degrees. The Admiral gave me many hours of pleasure. Thanks very much.
Added: 11/3/2002
Submitted by
Name: John Hettish
Comments:
"Hi Ted,
Thanks for taking the time to honor the Admiral. The documents are quite interesting to a fan of your grandfather such as I am. It was an honor talking with you that one time.
John Hettish"
Added: 11/2/2002
Submitted by
Name: Gordy
Comments:
"Ted, looks like things are taking off well. And to think that until a few years ago when I bought that movie poster that I never heard of EE. I'm sure that you are aware that I am now a BIG fan of his and his books. I just checked and saw that I have all of his books (known ) except three of them. They are S-54, Cruise of the Jeannette ,and Passport for Jennifer . Ted, I know that this is not a for sale web site b"
Submitted by
Name: mark mior
Comments:
"recently i read "under the red sea sun" and "on the bottom".i am truly impressed with the man and his writing.at this time i read only non fiction and personal experience is my favorite.i found ellsberg by accident at a used book sale.i am hooked, i can`t what to read no banners and the far shore .when i find them ."
Added: 3/21/2005
Submitted by
Name: Robert Clifford
Comments:
"I am in shock! I couldn't believe my eyes when, looking for books by one of my all time heroes, I found a website dedicated to him. My father was a WWII veteran of the CBI theater who was a great reader of adventure stories. My two brothers and I grew up in the 60's and 70's reading many of these books. Of all the books I have read in my life, never have I experienced an author who can captivate me to the extent that at 47 years of age, after a fairly adventurous life myself, I can settle down with "Under the Red Sea Sun" or "No Banners, No Bugles", both of which I have read cover to cover several times, and keep reading until I can't keep my eyes open any longer. For my late father, my two brothers, and I, an airman, soldier, and sailor, respectively, our eternal gratitude to the type of man of both action and thought who can write such compelling and inspirational works. I look forward now to exploring your website. Robert Clifford"
Added: 3/18/2005
Submitted by
Name: Glenn Lycan
Comments:
"While watching the TV program "Deep Sea Detectives", my wife asked where I became interested in diving. I said "That's easy to answer. While in high school in 1948 I found a book "On The Bottom" which started me in reading everything by Comander Ellsberg that I could find." His name has over the years has been the first search whenever I enter a library or bookstore.
Last evening when I found your website I could not go to bed until I finished reading the diary of the cruise on the Fairfax.
Thank You for keeping tour Grandfathers writings alive!"
Added: 2/26/2005
Submitted by
Name: Doyle Hodges
Comments:
"I am a Naval officer, on my way to command a salvage ship in the Pacific. I ran across a copy of On the Bottom in a used bookstore, and stumbled into this site by accident. Thanks for maintaining such a wonderful resource on a legend in Navy salvage."
Added: 2/26/2005
Submitted by
Name: Avi-Brillant
Comments:
"Under the Red-Sea Sun
By : Commander Edward Ellsberg
Very interesting book on WW2 salvage in the Red Sea.
I heard the name of Admiral Ellsberg from my late father. It was during an interview he gave to the Israeli Navy Veterans history branch from the Clandestine and Immigration Navy Museum in Haifa.There he told the story about his service in Massawa Eritrea and showed us many photos and Letters. Then I found in his Naval Technical Library he had several books of that time Commander Ellsber. One of them told his story. My father New CDR Ellsberg personally. This book describes the salvage work in the Massaawa harbor in Eritrea. This is a professional description of determined people in a hard climate area, that their goal was to bring back the Massaawa harbor into full operation for the allies. This is not a heroic war description with high strategy. This is the story of people. As a son of a Jewish Royal-Navy Officer volunteer from Palestine during the British mandate in Israel, I am familiar with this story. My father served there during 1942-1943. All the knowledge from his service was used by him to build the Young Israeli Navy in 1948. His experience from the service in the Royal Navy was used by him to define the Israeli Navy Salvage unit YALTAM and establishing all damage control branch as a professional unit. The Palestinians Jewish Volunteers in Massawa were very appreciated by the British and the Americans for their contribution in the war efforts against the evil Nazi regime. Admiral Ellsberg never hidden his origin and was a proud Jew. At the early strides he gave aid and guidance to the young Israeli Navy. But he was not the only one. For instance the Israeli Admiral of the Navy at its early days was USN Commander Paul-Schulman. My late father rank in the Israeli Navy was Lieutenant Commander. retired in 1962. His profession was Naval Architect. In 1969 he designed the fueling ship M.V Lea at the Gibraltar and the backup ship M.V Nethanyah at the Biscay bay for the Missile Boats. These boats were taken from the French by force by means of deception. This operation was during the French embargo led by the French presidents Charles De-Gulla and George Pompidou and is known as the Cherbourg Operation Noa. Those boats made the first sea to sea missile warfare in Naval History at 73. This is the first time ECM (electronic counter measures) and EW (electronic warfare) were used. It was a great victory without any single casualty to the Israeli Navy. This strategy was adopted by the USN. If any one is doing an history research on the Massawa Volunteers to the Royal-Navy from Israel (RNVR), or the Israeli Navy at the beginning send me an Email to Avi-Brillant Email address: avibrillant@hotmail.com To all interest on Navy I can recommend to read all the books of Admiral Ellsberg as well as to look for the book ?The Boats of Cherbourg? by Abraham Rabinovich.
All the best
Kol Toov
Shalom
Avi-Brillant"
Added: 2/24/2005
Submitted by
Name: David Farragut Rohde
Comments:
"Dear Ted
I am a Navy Junior (my Dad is a Retired Naval Officer) and I am a Marine. My professional library has many of your grandfather's books, and I have always enjoyed reading and re-reading them.
thanks very much for the nice website.
Semper Fi
David"
Added: 2/22/2005
Submitted by
Name: Richard De Luca
Comments:
"Commander Ellsberg was my first literary hero. I discovered him when I was in the ninth grade, and I enthusiastically read several of his books.
I recently acquired his "Under the Red Sea" and just finished reading it this morning. Wow!! What a man!!
I honor his memory.
Sincerely,
Dick De Luca"
Added: 2/22/2005
Submitted by
Name: MR.MUGU
Comments:
"Very good site, Divers are advised to check here.Good luck"
Added: 2/21/2005
Submitted by
Name: Steve Taylor
Comments:
"Mr. Pollard,I had no idea that there was a web site dedicated to Edward Ellsberg.Just out of curiousity I put his name in the browser and this site popped up. I have collected his books for years, my favorites have been Under the Red Sea Sun and No Banners No Bugles. I have read so much about him, I wished I could have met him personaly he was a true American Hero.Thanks for a web site honoring your Grandfather. Sincerely Steven J.Taylor"
Added: 2/13/2005
Submitted by
Name: Greg MacGarva
Comments:
"Dear Mr Pollard,
I have been a great fan of Admiral Ellsberg since the 3rd grade when I started reading On the Bottom and the rest of the books in that series. When I was in 4th grade I wrote a letter to him and much to my delight I received a very nice one in return which became a keepsake. I continued to read of his exploits in his non-fiction books as I got older. I am from a military family, my father having served in the Navy, Merchant Marine, and Coast Guard for a total of 30 years' service. I graduated from the Coast Guard Academy in 1976 and 1980 saw me as Assistant engineer on board a Polar Icebreaker. We spent many months in the ice, both north and south and during a north trip I read Hell on Ice, and I wrote him again and sent some photos of my ship. He again very kindly wrote me back - the handwriting reflecting a 14 year timespan since his previous letter, but what a wonderful letter and, like the other, it too remains a treasured keepsake.
Now my son will be carrying our military tradition forward another generation as he just received an appointment to Annapolis, Class of 2009. He too read many of Admiral Ellsberg's books growing up - when he was quite small and we were living in DC I took him to see the Naval Academy, and we viewed the limestone monument dedicated to the crew of the Jeannette.
Very sincerly,
Greg MacGarva
CDR, USCG (ret)
USCGA Class of 1976
P.S. The other day I wrote to the History Channel asking them why on earth they hadn't featured Admiral Ellsberg on a segment of "Biography"."
Added: 2/11/2005
Submitted by
Name: Emily Popovich
Comments:
Just finished Under The Red Sea Sun. What an amazing guy! Of course everyone around him would be inspired to work as hard as they could. So glad he was on our side!
Added: 2/3/2005
Submitted by
Name: JOHN EDWARDS
Comments:
"I have collected all of the Ellsberg books and have been a fan for many years, as a fellow diver and engineer I have nothing but admiration for his exploits."
Added: 1/29/2005
Submitted by
Name: Richard M. Huckeby
Comments:
"My 4th grade teacher, Mrs Whitlock, got me reading Ellsberg's novels in 1940. I devoured them and can even now quote from some of them.
I tried to introduce my own five children to these books in the 1960s but alas! could not find any of them.
Ellsberg made me want to be a naval officer (I lived in Denver--hardly a naval environment) but after I was unable to pass the eye exam for Naval ROTC at Colo Univ, I ended up going to law school.
I now live in Virgina, forty miles west of Norfolk, and can go look at boats and ships all I want.
But my fascination these days is with RC steamboats, typically 36" long, powered with live steam.
I used to know a lot about the Ellsberg underwater torch, but note it is not mentioned anywhere on your website"
Added: 1/20/2005
Submitted by
Name: Parker C. Wiseman
Comments:
"Dear Mr. Pollard,
Both I and my grand-father met RADM Ellsberg although at widely different times. I have written you a letter about our connections to your grandfather. Could you send me an e-mail message telling me where to send it? Here? Or elsewhere?
Thank you,
Parker C. Wiseman, Chatham, MA
Parker C. Wiseman, Chatham, MA"
Added: 1/18/2005
Submitted by
Name: william f. pack
Comments:
"interested in all navel salvage and navel ships,also wooden sailing ships.ALL FICTION"
Added: 12/31/2004
Submitted by
Name: Roy Rosenblum
Comments:
Thank you so much for a great website and tribute to one of my favorite authors. I read On the Bottom back in the late fourties and I was hooked. I read several more of his books and enjoyed everyone. At age 73 I still think back to CMDR Ellsberg and his formidable exploits. I now want to introduce him to my Grandson. Thanks again for the work you are doing in keeping your your grandfathers exploits alive..
Added: 12/25/2004
Submitted by
Name: David B Dawes
Comments:
"I live in Muskegon, Mi where we have four historic ships. No less than:USS 236, The 'Silversides' LST '393', USS 'MacLain', a 1927 Coast Guard Cutter and the USS 'Milwaukee Clipper', a ship tha tis oldert han the 'Titanic'. Your grandfather would just love these ships. John Niedermeir's son has actually been a guest speaker here and so has Edward Beach, Jr. Maybe you could come to visit sometime. I could personally give you a tour of each of these ships as I've done projects on all four of them. Let me know..."
Added: 12/12/2004
Submitted by
Name: Gary Wild
Comments:
"First read Under The Red Sea Sun in the mid '50's when in hi school, recently acquired my onw copy and appreciate the skill, work and all that was done for this country. We need more Edward Ellsberg's"
Added: 11/23/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Alan S. Pollack, Esq."
Comments:
"Hi Ted - We just met, I'm the videographer at Westfield Community Television. I just ordered a few books and will return to your great website to read more ! Thanks."
Added: 11/20/2004
Submitted by
Name: Jim Moody
Comments:
"I just finished reading On The Bottom for at least the fourth time. I first read it in high school around 1959. I was always intrigued by diving and even did some minor diving myself later. Then found it in the UWF library and read it again about 1990. About 2000 I copied it from online and read it again. I just recently dug the pages out of a manila folder, put them in a notebook binder and read it a fourth time. I'm hoping that it will not be the last time."
Added: 11/19/2004
Submitted by
Name: Ed Biggs
Comments:
Under the Red Sea Sun and No Banners No Bugles were both read in High School. They way they were written left a lasting memory. I have acquired Under the Red Sea Sun and have enjoyed it once again. My sons will get it to read as well. I much admire the American Hero Edward Ellsberg. EDB
Added: 11/18/2004
Submitted by
Name: Don Knott
Comments:
Thank you for making this available. Is it possible to purchase prints of photographs of his work. Such as the HMS Dido in dry dock at Massawa. Thank you.
Added: 11/7/2004
Submitted by
Name: "David T. Holland, CWO, U.S.C.G."
Comments:
I just completed reading "ON THE BOTTOM" in two days. What an inspirational read! It would have been an honor to work along side any of those men!
Added: 10/24/2004
Submitted by
Name: Charles Bauer
Comments:
I admired Adm. Ellsberg very much. He is one of my heroes!
Added: 9/30/2004
Submitted by
Name: Lawrence Jacobi
Comments:
I read on the bottom while in high school over 50 years ago. I was thrilled Flat Hammock Press released the book again.
Added: 8/26/2004
Submitted by
Name: Gregory Lee
Comments:
"I'm a Naval Architect. I Recently found & read Ellsberg Books, including Under the Red Sea Sun & Hell On Ice. Really first rate. I'm going to try to get copies of most of the other books by Ellsberg. Any sources you could identify would be helpful. I have the re-print of On the Bottom on order."
Added: 8/20/2004
Submitted by
Name: Edward Lukacs
Comments:
"If, in my lifetime, there was one naval officer who I'd have liked to meet, he was Edward Ellsberg. Discovering "Under the Red Sea Sun" in my elementary school's library, I eventually read every book that he wrolte, and own hardbound copies of all but one today. In an age that values ethics along with yesterday's unrefrigerated fish, I hope and pray that our country can again produce people of his calibre and with his drive, energy, and unwavering ethics."
Added: 8/19/2004
Submitted by
Name: Garry Greenstein
Comments:
"I started reading the Commander's books in Junior High School, and continued as an adult. I am a great admirer of his. GGG"
Added: 8/8/2004
Submitted by
Name: William Sumner
Comments:
"More than 40 years ago I first read Men Under The Sea. Recently, I found the book in storage-read it again. Where can I find other Ellsberg stories to read on the internet?"
Added: 8/7/2004
Submitted by
Name: John P. Kelley
Comments:
"As a boy I read every Ellsberg book I could find. When I took Diving Training with Class 13 EOD (1953) in Indian Head I knew where everything was and how it worked. All from reading LCDR Edward Ellsberg's books. I went into Nuclear and never dove again. Now in retirement I'm going to read the booka over again. I'm glad you took the trouble to put all this together. Thanks, Jack Kelley"
Added: 8/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: Henry Bick
Comments:
a most remarkable man.His work should never be forgotten.in my eyes a great hero.......
Added: 7/15/2004
Submitted by
Name: Mike Brush
Comments:
I found a copy of the new edition of On The Bottom at the book store recently and have been absolutley fascinated by what I have been reading. It's a great story. I wish I had learned about this a long time ago.
Added: 7/5/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Chip McCord, CAPT, USN (Ret)"
Comments:
RADM Ellsberg was an inspiration to generations of Divers and Salvors. He was the first (and still the best) in detailing the dangers and challenges while working on and under the ocean's surface (esp. in remote ares like Eritrea). Thanks for the website and keeping the memory of a true Navy Salvor alive.
Added: 7/2/2004
Submitted by
Name: Spencer Boyce
Comments:
I read your grandfather's books as a boy. No doubt that his writings contributed to my love of the sea and all things related to maritime salvage. Thanks for putting the website up.
Added: 6/28/2004
Submitted by
Name: Sue
Comments:
"Greetings. Your web site is very well done. Thank you for sharing your information. My great-uncle, Austin St. "Clair" Byrne worked on the salvage operations with Cmdr. Ellsberg. I have some info posted on my Byrne web site (link at left). Thanks again! Sue"
Added: 6/27/2004
Submitted by
Name: Terry A. Gardner
Comments:
"I first read Ellsbergs works, starting with Under the Red Sea Sun in high school. I now own my own copies of some of his works as well. Having spent 26 years in the US Navy and Reserve, I have found Ellsberg's books something of an inspiration to my own career in naval engineering.
Terry A. Gardner, EMC(SW) USNR"
Added: 6/21/2004
Submitted by
Name: Gary Kingzett
Comments:
"Thank you for helping us remember this great American. And now, since you and he have rekindled my memories, I will have to search for the rest of his books. Gary"
Added: 6/20/2004
Submitted by
Name: JERRY HODGE
Comments:
"Hi there i have read most of your grandfathers books. many years ago i just became aware though this website of the books i missed, I will be looking forward tom reading those as soon as possible, i wish i could have dived with commander Ellsberg in those days."
Added: 5/22/2004
Submitted by
Name: Alex Mello
Comments:
"Dear Sir,
Recently I became the temporary owner of a magnificent book entitled "Under The Red Sea Sun" written by your Grandfather. The book I have was published by Dodd, Mead & Company in 1946 and is in excellent condition. I can't remember the last time I read such an account of history with such desire and velocity. Your Grandfather may have passed away, but his inspiration as a man, a leader, and innovator will for always claim a piece of my memory.
Sincerely,
Alex Mello"
Added: 5/21/2004
Submitted by
Name: Steve Mellor
Comments:
Great work Ted. Ready to research other families?
Added: 4/26/2004
Submitted by
Name: Lew Nuckols
Comments:
"Ted, Great website!"
Added: 4/22/2004
Submitted by
Name: Doug Hender
Comments:
I have been a great fan of Edward Ellsberg since the late 1940's. Over the years I have read most of his books.
Added: 4/12/2004
Submitted by
Name: Chuck Milne
Comments:
"I borrowed "No Banners, No Bugles" from my uncle. Wonderful book! Amazing what he did with what he had."
Added: 4/11/2004
Submitted by
Name: Robert L Patch
Comments:
"My dad had several of his books and I read them as a preteen. Wanted to go into salvage but as bad eyesight would of limited me to internal ship work became an Engineer instead (Chemical, BS)."03/29/2004-15:20"
Added: 3/29/2004
Submitted by
Name: RAY SCHAEFER
Comments:
"GREAT SALVAGE ENGINEER, JUST WISH I COULD HAVE HAD A CHANCE TO WORK WITH HIM."
Added: 3/16/2004
Submitted by
Name: LAURENCE BAKER
Comments:
"Have read all of CMDR Ellsberg's books thru the years. Glad I found this Site for it has much information not otherwise available. My Heartfelt Thanks. LAURENCE BAKER, MSGT/USAF/RET"
Added: 3/2/2004
Submitted by
Name: Robert Ballou
Comments:
"Thank you for posting this web site and doing so much to honor your grandfather. I grew up reading his books after my older brother had finished reading them! His writing was so graphic that you could "see" everything in your minds eye. I'm now 64 and was unaware of the last book - The Far Shore - but now that I am, I will find a copy and read it for sure. Thanks again for all your efforts."
Added: 2/19/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Charles W. Roop, LCDR, USN (ret)"
Comments:
A great man and an inspiration to any of us who ever worked in ship salvage.
Added: 2/14/2004
Submitted by
Name: "Ralph Duncan, Lcdr, USN (Ret)"
Comments:
"I look forward to reading the biography. As a retired USN salvage officer, I too have admired the deeds of Edward Ellsberg. Under the Red Sea Sun, my favorite."
Added: 2/5/2004
Submitted by
Name: Sarah Hawke
Comments:
"I'm sorry, I couldn't get my web software to work correctly, and I didn't understand why those *'s kept showing up - I did not mean to flood this guestbook. Sorry :("
Added: 2/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: John
Comments:
"hi there, i really enjoyed your website."
Added: 2/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: D.G. Fitton
Comments:
"A terrific man, and fantastic author. My favorite. I have many copies of his books, having been collecting them for some time. I am interested in selling some of them, email me with your interest."
Added: 2/2/2004
Submitted by
Name: Michael R. Haeser
Comments:
In rememberance of Admiral Ellsberg who was a power of example to me since I read his first book "On The Bottom "when I was 11 years old and for my son who is about to be promoted to Chief Engineer in the United States Merchant Marine.
Added: 1/27/2004
Submitted by
Name: Paul Marak
Comments:
This is great ! I have read all of your father's books except Salvage man. I can only find it for $150. a little out of my price range.
Thank you Paul Marak
S/V Ryokosha in Mexico
Added: 1/21/2004
Submitted by
Name: John Hyatt
Comments:
Nice to have a new batch of letters (Normandy # 64-95) up since I last visited the site. Thanks! Are there more to come?
Added: 1/13/2004
Submitted by
Name: george hill
Comments:
"Thank you very much for the website. I also started reading in JrHS abt 1949 and he was my favorite author then and I still love and collect his books. I don't yet understand why people can be so brave. My first reaction to "Hell On Ice" was that it was just too morbid, but eventually I had to read it, and then was inspired by the terrific reserves of strength they called up, which we are normally very unaware. A friend collected EE's books at my request and so I have duplicates of Hell On Ice and Captain Paul if some one wants them. I would like to visit your library.
Thanks again."
Added: 1/6/2004
Submitted by
Name: John Bayer
Comments:
Glad to help anyone find any Ellsberg title used.
Added: 1/3/2004
Submitted by
Name: Edward Niedermair
Comments:
"A great web site for a great man! My dad, John C. Niedermair, was involved with the S-51 salvage and the book "On The Bottom" is very dear to me. I wanted to purchase the new edition and could not come up with it on Amazon. It would be nice if this site had a link to the purchase of all of Admiral Ellsbergs wonderful books. "
Added: 12/17/2003
Submitted by
Name: Janet Young
Comments:
I read Passport for Jennifer about 10 years ago. There was a copy in the library. I often think about it and appreciate all what these folks went through.
Added: 12/5/2003
Submitted by
Name: john f shima
Comments:
"I have been a fan of Cmdr Elsberg since the age of 9, having read all his books. Served in the USN as QM on PCS in Key West. He was the first author I ever followed."
Added: 12/3/2003
Submitted by
Name: Paul L. Kidd
Comments:
"On a recent pilgrimage to Portsmouth, NH, I found an excellent old copy of "On The Bottom," which I am now enjoying immensely. As an old Smoke Boat sailor (Ret.) I consider myself something of an amature historian on submarine disasters. You can appreciate how glad I was to find this excellent website!"
Added: 11/11/2003
Submitted by
Name: Andrew Melomet
Comments:
Picked up a copy of Pigboats from Abebooks.com. and am preparing a 2004 presentation of Hell Below for the Bay Area chapters of The Great War Society. Bought the 2 books available from Flat Hammock Press. Any possibility of future reprints such as the WWII trilogy? This is a superb website and I'm glad I found it.
Added: 11/7/2003
Submitted by
Name: Anne Trembley
Comments:
I only wish they would print a new enlarged edition of the biography so I could read it. But I understand the Navy does not like attention drawn to men who succeed against impossible odds.
Added: 10/30/2003
Submitted by
Name: George Herold
Comments:
"I was on the S-27 1941/1942 until it was lost 19 June "42. I confess not having read much of his stuff, but will visit library for sure now."
Added: 10/4/2003
Submitted by
Name: Andy Werback
Comments:
"His books are just incredible. Under the Red Sea Sun is an amazing story of what it took to get the job done. I've managed to check a few of the events he describes, such as a Liberty ship blowing up off North Africa, fully documented elsewhere."
Added: 9/19/2003
Submitted by
Name: Tom Ellsberg
Comments:
I was supprised to see so many people still interested in my Uncle.
Added: 9/9/2003
Submitted by
Name: Jerry Guenther
Comments:
I have collected and read all of Edwards books and have read some of them two and three times. Can you help me locate a copy of Aldens book Ellsberg and the U.S. navy. Thanks very much. Jerry guenther
Added: 8/25/2003
Submitted by
Name: Joseph J. Gannon
Comments:
As a young boy (now 58) I thrilled to the tales in Commander Ellsberg's books. I brought him up at dinner to someone who was applauding the new book on the Squalus rescue. JJG
Added: 8/20/2003
Submitted by
Name: dennis f morse
Comments:
nice site. i am a retired usn master diver. also i was one of four divers who salvaged the andrea doria statue from the ship of the same name.
Added: 8/11/2003
Submitted by
Name: Sandra Straub
Comments:
"I was wondering if there is any way I can get a copy of the book "Blow All Ballast"? My father was on the ship that rescued them (Falcon, I think) and his name in mentioned in the book - John Burton Smith. Thank you for your help."
Added: 8/8/2003
Submitted by
Name: Craig Rothhammer
Comments:
"Thank you for dedicating this excellent website to your Grandfathers Naval career. He is a beacon for all Naval Salvors, and our respect and admiration for him is fathomless.
Anchor's Aweigh
Craig Rothhammer
Board Member
National Association of Fleet Tug Sailors - the Salvage Navy.
"The Difficult We Do Today, The Impossible May Take Until Tomorrow"
Added: 7/10/2003
Submitted by
Name: Steve Masticola
Comments:
"Just finished No Banners, No Bugles last night. Was wondering why, when he was trying to raise the Grand Dock, he didn't think of substituting easy-to-make mercury or water manometers for the low-preessure gauges that he couldn't get. That's the one place I caught him not taking advantage of every possible opportunity, but I guess he had an excuse that he was about to collapse from nervous exhaustion. Excellent book."
Added: 7/9/2003
ubmitted by
Name: Montgomery Sabin
Comments:
"I read most of Edward Ellsberg's books when I was a youngster. In fact, I used to hide one his books inside my regular class room text book and read it during class instead of the what I was supposed to be reading. Loved each and every word in every book and wish that he could have written more and more."
Added: 7/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: Thomas Tully
Comments:
Correction to last message. After"Under The Red Sea Sun"1946 should read "no Banners No Bugles"(1949).Then The Far Shore"(1959). Tom Tully
Added: 6/28/2003
Submitted by
Name: Thomas Tully
Comments:
"First read "On The Bottom" as a H.S. english Assignment in 1948 and have been interested.in him ever since. I have read almost all of his books and have "On The Bottom" (1955)," Under The Red Sea Sun(1946),"Under The Red Sea Sun"(1949)and "No Banners,No Bugles"(pocket book(1959).A friend found this site for me trying to find "salvage Man" after I saw a review in "Sea Classics" magazine.Please let me know when and if you con get it published again.
Thomas Tully"
Added: 6/28/2003
Submitted by
Name: James Myers
Comments:
"I was a big fan of Adm. Ellsburg, my first book was "On the Bottom". That was in the 1970's, my one real regret was not tracking him down and getting him to sign my copy."
Added: 6/21/2003
Submitted by
Name: Mark Mooney
Comments:
"Finally got to start 'Captain Paul' which I rediscovered recently in my library, having claimed it from my Grandparents estate a few years ago. I'm an amateur Naval History buff and am totally enthralled with this JPJ Novel which launched a web search to discover more on author and book. Do you have any idea how much of this 'Novel' is based on factual events? It wonderful to discover an alumni with such literary skill(amongst many other talents, I see in viewing the website). USNA 1978."
Added: 6/20/2003
Submitted by
Name: Jean York
Comments:
"My father is a big fan of Edward Ellsberg. Any advice on where/how to find copies of his books? He already has Captain Paul, Hell on Ice, Thirty Fathoms Deep, and On the Bottom. The others are pretty tough to locate. And thanks for a great web-site!"
Added: 6/16/2003
Submitted by
Name: John Bayer
Comments:
"Hello Ted: Great site on your Grandfather! I am a Naval Reserve officer on recall to active duty. Having had 4 different ratings as an enlisted man during 24 years enlisted service, I was fortunate to have attended 2nd Class DV school in San Diego in 1984. I didn't finish after deciding to leave active duty at the time. Your Grandfather's writings were what inspired me to go there in the first place, however, and to one day pursue underwater archaeology. Our class had our familiarization dives in the few remaining Mark V suits, as the transition to the Mk 12 was happening... hope you have fun with your dive with Dave!
Any word on the reprint of the Alden book?
Sincerely,
John Bayer
ENS, USNR (ex-IS1, QM1, AW1)"
Added: 6/7/2003
Submitted by
Name: Jim Allen
Comments:
"Ted,
Great website. I especially enjoyed the WWII letters. By a sheer and magnificent coincidence, I stumbled upon this website while rereading my old copy of "On the Bottom." I think I'll start on "Under the Red Sea Sun" next. Ted, we haven't spoken for some time, but I'm glad the iography on your grandfather got done... even if it wasn't by me! Best Wishes. Jim Allen"
Added: 6/3/2003
Submitted by
Name: Eric Anderson
Comments:
"I found the books "Under the Red Sea Sun" and "No Bugles, No Banners" in my high school library, and was hooked - more that 20 years ago! As a working engineer, I would like to read more of his technical papers, as well as re-reading his books. I was shocked to find out that he was not listed at the Navy Memorial Museum when I visited in 2000 - and I firmly believe that the Navy is overdue in naming a ship for him - And the Salvage School!!! I had thought that the neglect was due to RADM Ellsberg being Jewish, but I see that it was also due to his being a Naval Constructor, rather than a Line Officer... The Senators from Colorado and New York should get signed up for this!"
Added: 5/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: David H. Grover
Comments:
"As a long-time Ellsworth reader and fan, I'm delighted that he is being re-discovered as one of the real heroes of World War II. As a long-ago graduate of the Navy Salvage School I can attest to the fact that the salvage establishment did not assist in publicizing his accomplishments. As a writer these days, I'll try to do what I can to apread the word about his role in salvage work. Dave Grover"
Added: 4/21/2003
Submitted by
Name: Laurel Jacobs
Comments:
I am interested in Edward Ellsberg because I am trying to find a book that my Uncle needs to complete his collection. It is Passport For Jennifer. If anyone knows where I can get a copy - Please email me.
Added: 3/29/2003
Submitted by
Name: Leonard Schechtman
Comments:
I am a big fan.
Added: 3/29/2003
Submitted by
Name: Bob Cloutman
Comments:
Great site Ted. I think you know what a fan I am of your grandfather. I couldn't be happier that someone is preserving his legacy.
Added: 1/31/2003
Submitted by
Name: Joel M. Kauffman
Comments:
Enjoyed the fiction as a teenager. Realized what an honest hero Ellsberg was by reading the non-fiction. Wow!
Added: 1/28/2003
Submitted by
Name: Steve Masticola
Comments:
"I ran into Under the Red Sea Sun quite by accident. Although I'd read at least one other excellent book about salvage (Gray Seas Under by Mowat), I'd never known that the business could be so fascinating. Comander Ellsberg was an excellent writer and a real hero. I hope we're still making men like him."
Added: 1/15/2003
Submitted by
Name: Charles Hall
Comments:
Nice looking website! Now if you can get his other books back in print!
Added: 1/14/2003
Submitted by
Name: Frank T. Chapman
Comments:
I have an original copy of "On The Bottom" since sometime in the 1940s. I have read it several times and it is always exciting. I'm happy to see it reprinted.
Added: 1/9/2003
Submitted by
Name: David J Young
Comments:
I was stationed in Ethiopia in the mid '60's and it was a nice day when I discovered "Under the Red Sea Sun" in a flea market. Edward Ellsberg was a fascinating man and have enjoyed two other books he's written.Great countries are made by great men.
Added: 1/3/2003
Submitted by
Name: Bill Barnum
Comments:
Boy could he write.If you read them all I agree the Navy should name a ship in his name.
Added: 1/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: REFIK ABBAS
Comments:
"Hello,
I became a diver because I was directed by two men : J.Y. Cousteau and the author of no banners, no bugles, the admiral E. Elsberg. Really thanks for your site .
R.ABBAS from Algeria"
Added: 1/2/2003
Submitted by
Name: Robert H. Arbuckle Jr.
Comments:
Ellsberg was a true hero.
Added: 1/1/2003
Submitted by
Name: Lee Parsons
Comments:
"I am a fan of all of Edward's Ellsbergs books. I have been unable to find a copy of 'S-54', any suggestions?"
Added: 12/28/2002
Submitted by
Name: John T. Thurmond
Comments:
"Glad to see that the author of two of my favored books back in high school -- maybe before, has some well deserved attention. The two were, of course "Red Sea Sun" and "No Banners." Trying to be a novelist in my retirement (a fossil expert trying to evade becoming one myself) and used an incident -- the raising of "Spahi" at Oran -- as the basis for something just written. "
Added: 12/22/2002
Submitted by
Name: Mark Stoffan
Comments:
"I grew up reading Edward Ellsberg's books in junior high and high school, and own copies of some of them. I didn't know at the time that he was still alive and living quite close to me in Maine. I've since regretted that I never had the chance to meet him. He was a brilliant man, a credit to the Navy and his country, and he should be better remembered than he is. Perhaps we should petition the Navy to name a ship in Ellsberg's memory. I hope you are successful in getting Alden's bio republished. We have one of the 1500 original copies in our library. "
Added: 12/20/2002
Submitted by
Name: Jeffrey M. Lane
Comments:
"Great site, I am a former Army Diver and am interested in all stories and accounts about military diving I can find. Looking forward to going down the list of publications!!"
Added: 12/19/2002
Submitted by
Name: Norm Mitchell
Comments:
Like so many I read Comm. E.E. books in Jr. High in the 1950s. About 10 yrs. ago went looking for copies of his books. Have reread and have copies of most of them. What examples of outstanding human character traits. Wish these books could be introducted to our Jr. Highers today. Thanks very much for this web site. Question what ever happend to the bell S-51 that EE gave to Francis Smith? what ever happen to F.Smith?
Added: 12/17/2002
Submitted by
Name: Ralph K. Pedersen
Comments:
"I came across "Under the Red Sea Sun" quite by accident. I find it thoroughly engrossing particulary as I myself have spent time in Massawa and Eritrea (as an underwater archaeologist)dealing with the intractable. Great book, and I look forward to reading more!"
Added: 12/17/2002
Submitted by
Name: Zalman Lachman
Comments:
"I picked up "On The Bottom" at a used bookstore several years ago, and enjoyed it especially for the way the average reader is introduced to the arcane world of underwater salvage and hard-helmet diving. I have always wanted to know more about your grandfather's life, and Alden's book is very difficult to find. Thank you for sharing the details here, Ted. This is a wonderful site. In my opinion, though it is not autobiographical, "Hell On Ice," is the best written and most gripping of the Ellsberg titles."
Added: 12/12/2002
Submitted by
Name: Jay Clarke
Comments:
I remember reading "Under the Red Sea Sun" and "On the Bottom" in High School in the late 50's. Great Story. I thought of it today and ran a search and found this wedsite. Glad to honor this wonderful author and adventurer.
Added: 12/11/2002
Submitted by
Name: Mike Van Hove
Comments:
"As a boy in Jr Hi, I read a series of books about subs and salvaging subs. They were written (I tought) by a Commander Edward Ellsberg. Seems like the stories had a common crew woven into the various books. I looked at the list of books on your website, but nothing sounds familiar. Is there another author by the name of Edward Ellberg? They were great stories and I'd like to get them for my Grandsons to read, but havn't had any luck at the library. Am I just not remembering correctly, or is it the trilogy that I read, years ago. Seems like there were far more that just 3 books in the series. If you have the time, I'd love to hear from you. I just came across your Grandfathers name in Vol III of Samuel Elliot Morisons "History of Naval Operations in World War II", where he is mentioned for his salvage work in North Africa. That name jumped off the page at me, and here I am. Thank you for maintaining this site!!
Mike Van Hove
mvanhove@earthlink.net"
Added: 12/10/2002
Submitted by
Name: Michael B. Achorn
Comments:
"I first read "Under the Red Sea Sun", some 45 years ago. Thanks to EBay I have my own copy of this wondrful book. Nice to see RADM Ellsberg is remembered."
Added: 11/30/2002
Submitted by
Name: Dave Sutton
Comments:
"Kudus to Ted for keeping the flame of his Grandfathers work alive. Ted: We'll get you diving in that Mark-V helmet this spring, I promise!
Respectfully,
Dave Sutton"
Added: 11/29/2002
Submitted by
Name: John A. Hyatt
Comments:
"What a delight to discover the Ellsberg website! Finding the WWII letters was a particular treat - I've printed them all out and will read through them some wintry evening soon.
I read "On The Bottom" and several of the novels while in high school in the '60's, and since then I have re-read "On The Bottom" and "Under the Red Sea Sun" every 5 years or so. My interest in marine salvage and diving is only of the armchair variety, but Ellsberg has remained to this day a hero and role model to me: A man who knew how to get things done, and who cared more about the accomplishment of useful tasks than the mere appearance and trappings of success. "
Added: 11/15/2002
Submitted by
Name: "Col. Lee Butler, US Army, Ret."
Comments:
Admiral Ellsberg was on of my favorite authors when I was growing up. He introduced me to th adventures of ocean salvage. Commander Ellsberg (as he was called when he wrote some of the books I read) was one of the many authors who affected my life in varying degrees. The Admiral gave me many hours of pleasure. Thanks very much.
Added: 11/3/2002
Submitted by
Name: John Hettish
Comments:
"Hi Ted,
Thanks for taking the time to honor the Admiral. The documents are quite interesting to a fan of your grandfather such as I am. It was an honor talking with you that one time.
John Hettish"
Added: 11/2/2002
Submitted by
Name: Gordy
Comments:
"Ted, looks like things are taking off well. And to think that until a few years ago when I bought that movie poster that I never heard of EE. I'm sure that you are aware that I am now a BIG fan of his and his books. I just checked and saw that I have all of his books (known ) except three of them. They are S-54, Cruise of the Jeannette ,and Passport for Jennifer . Ted, I know that this is not a for sale web site b"